No one feeds their child an entire loaf of bread in one sitting. In the same way, every sermon needs one main idea. Not five ideas. One.
If your listeners can’t say what the sermon was about in one sentence on the way home, you probably didn’t have one idea yourself. You had a pile of good material and no spine to hold it together.
Some call that idea the bullet. A sermon needs to be a bullet, not buckshot. Buckshot scatters. A bullet hits one target. Give your people a couple of slices of bread for a sandwich, not a whole loaf they can’t finish.
Here’s the part many preachers get wrong. The big idea isn’t something you brainstorm and then dress up with a Bible passage. It’s something you discover by digging into the passage first. And you can only discover it after the steps before it are done, in their order.
But what if the Spirit gives you the idea first?
Some preachers will push back here. They’ll say the main idea came to them while they were driving, or in prayer, or in the middle of the week – the Spirit led them to it before they ever sat down to study. That can happen, and I won’t deny it.
But an idea that arrives in the car still has to survive the passage. Scripture tells us to test what we hear: “Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God” (1 John 4:1). And the test itself is the written Word: “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them” (Isaiah 8:20).
So the digging isn’t doubt. It’s the test. If the idea the Spirit gave you is truly from Him, you’ll find it waiting in the text when you dig – and then it’s no longer just an impression from the drive. It’s the passage’s own idea, confirmed. If you can’t find it there, it wasn’t the passage speaking, and it shouldn’t be the sermon.
The order comes first
My sermon preparation form has 12 steps, and every step builds on the last. You can’t skip ahead and each step must be bathed in prayer. Here’s the part of the order that matters for the big idea.
Step 1: pick the preaching passage and the purpose. Why this sermon? Does it touch your own life? Does it meet a need in your congregation or your community? Does it fit a season of the year?
Step 2: dig into the passage. Look at the context around it, the context of the whole book, and the literary setting. Study the key words, including the original language when it matters. Ask what was happening when the author wrote, and what the author wrote elsewhere on the same topic. This is the long work, and it’s the enjoyable work. It also maps out future sermons, because the context you study for one sermon often holds three more.
Only then do you get to the idea. And here’s the second ordering rule that saves sermons: outside material comes after you discovered the big idea of the text, not before it. Facts, quotes, and illustrations wait until you know what the passage actually says. If a good illustration doesn’t fit the idea, it gets cut. An illustration picked first will pull your sermon off the text every time.
Find it in three moves
Once you’ve dug into the passage, the exegetical idea comes in three simple moves.
First, state the subject as a question. Who or what is the text talking about?
Second, answer that question from the text. This answer is called the complement. It must come from the passage itself, not from what you already believe is there. You’re finding the idea, not imposing one.
Third, put the two together. That one sentence is the exegetical idea. It says what the author was saying to the first hearers.
Then you shape it into a biblical idea for your hearers today. That takes three checks. What does this mean for their lives right now? Can they actually believe it, and why? And who cares: what difference does it make?
Then comes the bullet. Take the idea and press it into one short, memorable line your sermon will keep coming back to. I usually write six to eight bullets and pick my favorite. The bullet is what your people will remember on Monday.
Two examples from my own preparation
Let me show you with two passages I’ve preached.
Matthew 7:24-29: the wise and foolish builders at the end of the Sermon on the Mount. The subject as a question: How can someone be considered wise? The complement, straight from the text: when they hear Jesus’ instructions and actually do what He says. Put them together, and the exegetical idea is this: when someone hears Jesus’ instructions, they’ll be considered wise if they do them.
Now the biblical idea. What does it mean today? When you become a Christian but don’t do what Christ calls you to do, you’re building on unstable ground. Can your hearers believe it? Yes, because it comes straight from the mouth of Jesus, with an illustration He chose Himself. Who cares? The stakes are high. This isn’t just about looking wise. It’s about standing when the storms of life and sin hit. Since we followed the steps in order, the bullet becomes easy to find: Be wise: trust and obey – your life depends on it.
Ephesians 5:22-33: on marriage. After digging through the text, we find the overarching instruction coming from verse 21 calling for mutual submission in Christian households. The subject then is an evident question: How should wives and husbands submit to one another? The complement: wives voluntarily submit to their husbands as to the Lord, and husbands love their wives sacrificially, as Christ loved the church. The main message has to stay faithful to Paul’s main message. You can bring in culture, felt needs, and explanation, but the core must not drift.
The biblical idea here redefines power as service. Marriage isn’t about winning arguments or lording power over your mate. It’s about mutual faithfulness. Homes like that preach a sermon without saying a word. The bullet was: submit and sacrifice like Jesus.
Notice what happened in both cases. The idea came from the text after the digging. It wasn’t chosen first and proven later.
Three mistakes to avoid
First, imposing an idea on the text. If you decide the message before you study, you’ll find a way to make the passage say it, whether it’s faithful to the text or not.
Second, picking illustrations before the idea is fixed. A great story that doesn’t fit the idea will bend your sermon away from the passage.
Third, preaching everything you learned. Study always gives you more than you can share. That’s part of the beauty of being a preacher. But your sermon isn’t your study notes. It’s one idea, presented well.
The one step you can’t hand to a tool
I need to say one more thing plainly. AI should never lead a preacher during sermon prep in any way. It can easily replace the leading of the Holy Spirit, and it can substitute for the preacher’s hard-won experience in preparing, synthesizing, and internalizing God’s word.
That matters most right here, at the big idea. Idea-forming is the step where your own discovery does the work. A tool can help with mechanics elsewhere. But if a tool hands you the idea, the sermon has no spine, because the spine was never yours. I’ll be writing a full post on AI in sermon prep soon, and I’ll lay out the whole position there.
Trust the order
Passage, then digging. Exegetical idea, then biblical idea, then bullet. Only then the supporting material. A preacher who trusts that order walks into the weekend with one idea worth preaching, instead of a pile of notes and a prayer that it holds together. If you have too many good ideas to share in one sermon, turn it into a sermon series. I’ll be talking more about this in another blog post.
If you want to practice this process one step a day, my free 5-Day Challenge walks you through the core of it. Sign up for the free 5-Day Challenge
You already have the passage. Go dig in it. The idea is in there waiting.
0 Comments